Hoosier Enquirer

Your Source for Indiana News

Indiana News

Breaking News

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

top of page

Todd Rokita Should Be Governor—Just So Indiana’s Disciplinary Establishment Gets to Face the Question, Why?

10 minutes ago
3 min read
Is he purging the stronger conservative candidate and giving into Rush?
Is he purging the stronger conservative candidate and giving into Rush?

By the Hoosier Enquirer Editorial Board | Opinion

INDIANAPOLIS — Todd Rokita should be Indiana’s next governor. His confrontation with the state’s attorney-disciplinary establishment offers a reason to consider him: he is challenging an institution that exercises extraordinary power over lawyers while facing too little independent scrutiny itself.


The Hoosier Enquirer has reported the nearly half-million dollars spent defending Rokita in disciplinary matters. Those expenditures deserve disclosure. But a story that stops at his legal bills leaves the institution generating those disputes insufficiently examined. Who scrutinizes the investigators? What happens when professional regulation becomes entangled with political opposition? And what protection exists for an ordinary attorney who cannot afford a prolonged defense?


The Indiana Capital Chronicle reported that four private firms received a combined $491,508 in public funds between 2022 and 2025 for Rokita’s representation in at least six disciplinary matters. Only two investigations produced formal disciplinary charges. That does not establish that the other investigations were improper. It does establish that the defense bill cannot fairly be treated as a bill for proven misconduct alone. indianacapitalchronicle.com

A meaningful accounting should examine the Commission’s expenditures alongside the defense costs, the duration of investigations and the reasons matters ended. Taxpayers deserve to understand the decisions that generated the spending.


Rokita’s federal lawsuit, filed October 1, 2026, alleges retaliation, excessive investigations and improper disclosure of confidential disciplinary information. Those allegations remain unproven. They nevertheless concern the conduct of public officials and deserve examination on their merits.


Among the complaint’s allegations is that commissioner Bernard Carter supported Rokita’s election opponent while the Commission was investigating him. An endorsement alone does not prove biased enforcement. The institutional question is whether conflict disclosures and recusal procedures adequately protect a respondent when a regulator participates in the respondent’s electoral opposition. The public deserves an answer grounded in records. indianacitizen.org


Chief Justice Loretta Rush and Executive Director Adrienne Meiring should face demanding questions about the system they lead and administer. Rush’s leadership should be judged by the fairness, consistency and accountability of the disciplinary structure under the Court’s authority. Meiring’s administration deserves equally close scrutiny. Neither should receive a presumption that criticism of the institution is an attack on justice. Those two ladies must go and if Braun can't do it, then he must go too!


The chronology also deserves accuracy. Rokita’s second disciplinary case ended in October 2025 after the Court accepted an agreement reaffirming his earlier acceptance of responsibility and dismissed the matter as moot. The earlier reprimand remains part of the record. The dismissal was not an exoneration, but neither should the second case be presented as still pending. www.in.gov


The harder question concerns lawyers without Rokita’s resources. A sole practitioner facing an investigation must find counsel, gather records and spend time away from clients while worrying about a livelihood. Even a dismissed grievance can carry substantial costs. A fair system must protect clients while ensuring that its own procedures do not impose avoidable financial and professional damage.


That is why this newspaper supports renewed consideration of Doug’s Law: independent, nonbinding mediation for suitable attorney-client disputes before they escalate into disciplinary proceedings or malpractice litigation. The proposal calls for an initial two-hour session, with the client and lawyer each paying for one hour. Unresolved claims could proceed, and the mediator could report suspected misconduct. Urgent matters involving theft, serious dishonesty or immediate danger would require prompt regulatory action.

Indiana should also establish a credible review process for attorneys presenting substantial evidence of wrongful discipline. Where a review establishes that a sanction rested on materially false evidence or denied required procedural protections, meaningful relief—including reinstatement when warranted—should follow.


These reforms require more than campaign rhetoric. A governor cannot simply order the Supreme Court to restore licenses or dismiss cases. A reform-minded governor can press for public hearings, independent examination, transparent spending and cooperation with the judiciary on changes within each branch’s authority.


That is the case for Rokita over Braun: a demand for sustained leadership on an issue that reaches beyond one politician. Braun should be challenged to offer an equally concrete reform program. Rokita, if he seeks the governorship, should explain how his challenge would produce protections for every Indiana lawyer and legal consumer.


The Commission must be able to investigate genuine misconduct. It must also be accountable for how it uses that power. HE’s position is that Rokita should carry this fight into a governing agenda: fair procedures, independent scrutiny and remedies when the system gets a case wrong. Indiana deserves that debate, and the disciplinary establishment should have to participate in it.

bottom of page