Hoosier Enquirer

Your Source for Indiana News

Indiana News

Breaking News

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

top of page

Governor Race: Affordability Debate Has a Missing Piece, The Cost of Justice

11 minutes ago
5 min read
Hill Would Address it. When you are rich like Braun you have lawyers.  Braun has not checked the SCOIN and it matters.
Hill Would Address it. When you are rich like Braun you have lawyers. Braun has not checked the SCOIN and it matters.

Governor Mike Braun has emphasized gasoline prices and household expenses. But the growing difficulty of finding and paying for legal representation raises another question for Indiana's next gubernatorial campaign—and an opportunity for former Attorney General Curtis Hill to put judicial reform on the agenda.


INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana Governor Mike Braun is preparing for reelection with affordability as a central political message. His administration has emphasized gasoline-tax relief and the cost of living, while Republicans and Democrats in the newly organized General Assembly are debating utility bills, housing, child care and property taxes. Yet one of the most consequential expenses facing Indiana families rarely appears in those discussions: the cost of obtaining justice.


A homeowner fighting foreclosure, a parent navigating a custody dispute, a small-business owner facing litigation or a worker challenging an unlawful dismissal may discover that hiring an attorney is financially impossible. In some rural communities, finding an available lawyer can be a problem even for people prepared to pay. Unlike gasoline prices, legal expenses cannot be reduced by a temporary tax suspension. And unlike ordinary consumer purchases, legal representation may be necessary to protect a person's home, livelihood or constitutional rights.


This is an affordability issue that deserves the same attention as household energy bills. It also raises a question about the 2028 governor's race: Will any candidate make the availability of affordable legal services a serious statewide priority?


Braun's affordability campaign fails to meet Indiana's legal deserts


Braun announced his reelection campaign on November 16 at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway Museum, promising a 92-county affordability tour. He pointed to property-tax relief, gasoline-tax suspensions, child-care assistance and efforts to restrain utility rates as evidence that his administration is responding to household financial pressures. Those initiatives have identifiable benefits, although their long-term costs and distribution remain subjects of debate.


The problem is that Indiana's shortage of lawyers is neither hypothetical nor confined to a handful of remote communities. The Indiana Supreme Court has acknowledged that the state ranks 48th nationally in working residental lawyers per capita, while the Indiana State Bar Association reported in 2025 that more than half of Indiana's counties met the definition of a legal desert, with fewer than one attorney per 1,000 residents. The Court's own current list identifies 49 counties meeting its legal-desert criteria.


The consequences extend well beyond rural courthouses. A family earning too much to qualify for free legal assistance may still be unable to afford a private attorney. Indiana University researchers have been exploring nonprofit law firms precisely because conventional legal services are often priced beyond the reach of moderate-income households. Family-law disputes and debt-collection matters are among the areas identified for potential assistance.


This shortage also has implications for economic development. Small businesses need lawyers to negotiate leases, resolve contractual disputes and handle regulatory obligations. Rural communities need prosecutors, public defenders, estate-planning attorneys and lawyers willing to represent clients in ordinary civil disputes. When those services become scarce, legal problems become more expensive, harder to resolve and more likely to disrupt families and businesses.


Curtis Hill and the question of judicial reform


Former Attorney General Curtis Hill presents an interesting contrast to Braun because his public career was built around criminal prosecution, law enforcement and the administration of justice. Before serving as Indiana attorney general from 2017 to 2021, Hill spent years as Elkhart County prosecutor. His background would give reporters a substantial record to examine should he seek to make legal affordability or judicial reform part of another gubernatorial campaign.


Hill also has a complicated history with Indiana's legal establishment. In 2020, the Indiana Supreme Court suspended his law license for 30 days after finding that he committed professional misconduct involving unwanted physical contact with four women. Hill disputed the allegations, and no criminal charges were filed. Any serious examination of his possible political return must account for that history alongside his experience in public office.


The question is not whether Hill's past disciplinary dispute establishes that Indiana's attorney-regulation system is unjust. It does not. Rather, his experience places him in a position to address questions about due process, the consistency of professional sanctions, and the proper limits of the judiciary's authority over lawyers. Whether he would support reforms to those systems remains to be established through his own statements and proposals.


Nor should Indiana's attorney shortage be attributed exclusively to Braun. The Supreme Court has constitutional authority over admission to the practice of law and professional discipline, and the shortage predates his administration. In 2024, the Court established the Commission on Indiana's Legal Future, acknowledging the seriousness of the problem and proposing changes involving rural practice incentives, licensing pathways and alternative legal-service models.


That division of responsibility is precisely why the next governor's policy agenda matters. Although the governor cannot simply rewrite Supreme Court disciplinary judgments, the executive and legislative branches can support scholarships, rural-practice incentives, legal-aid funding and legislation that removes unnecessary barriers to delivering affordable legal services. They can also press for greater public accountability without compromising judicial independence.


A different test of affordability


Indiana's political debate would benefit from moving beyond the assumption that affordability can be measured primarily at the gasoline pump. A temporary suspension of fuel taxes is visible, relatively easy for motorists to understand, and capable of producing immediate savings. It does not, however, address the structural costs of obtaining legal representation or the absence of attorneys in underserved counties.


The distinction is important because legal affordability is often a matter of access rather than marginal savings. A household that saves several dollars filling its vehicle may still face thousands of dollars in legal expenses when confronted with a divorce, eviction, inheritance dispute or civil lawsuit. A small business that cannot locate an affordable attorney may postpone expansion or leave a contractual dispute unresolved. The economic consequences are real even though they rarely appear in the monthly inflation figures politicians cite.


Indiana's judiciary has begun responding to the shortage through its legal-future commission, and the State Bar Association has proposed incubator programs, alternative pathways to licensure and incentives for rural practice. Those efforts deserve measurable goals and public evaluation. The next administration and General Assembly should be expected to explain how their budgets and policies complement that work rather than treating access to justice as a problem belonging exclusively to the courts.


The 2028 gubernatorial campaign offers an opportunity to ask both Braun and any prospective challenger, including Hill, what they would do to expand the supply of legal services, reduce unnecessary costs and ensure that ordinary Hoosiers can obtain competent representation. Hill's prosecutorial background and experience as attorney general provide a basis for examining his proposals. Braun's record provides a basis for measuring what his administration has already accomplished and what remains undone.


Indiana voters should receive specific answers from both. The state has documented a substantial lawyer shortage, and the effects reach families, businesses and local governments. An affordability agenda that overlooks the cost of justice leaves an important part of household and economic security unaddressed.


A state cannot claim to have solved its affordability problems while large numbers of residents struggle to find or pay for the lawyers needed to protect their rights, Hill would getter done and CJ Rush would get her karma.

bottom of page