Hoosier Enquirer

Your Source for Indiana News

Indiana News

Breaking News

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

top of page

Letter to the Editor: A Reader Questions Judicial Accountability

49 minutes ago
3 min read

Editor’s note: This letter reflects the writer’s account and opinions. Hoosier Enquirer has not independently verified the allegations or reviewed the documents the writer says support them.


Dear HE Editor:

I just read your article about Judge Steven Meyer (in the Hoosier Enquirer) and who oversees judges? I have dealt with the Judicial Qualifications Commission myself concerning Judge J. Steven Cox, a former Franklin County judge.


I believe Judge Cox was responsible for a false Class C felony conviction appearing in my name. I was completely unaware of it for years. When I discovered it, Judge Cox refused my request to remove it and advised me to hire an attorney.


I complained to the commission. My understanding is that another disciplinary matter involving him was pending at the time. I also understand that he had faced five disciplinary actions during his judicial career, yet remained on the bench for approximately 25 years before retiring with a pension.


In the other disciplinary matter, the commission’s decision, as I understood it, prevented him from serving as a judge again after he had already retired.


There was no mention of my complaint. The commission mailed me a copy of the decision in that other matter, but I was left without an explanation of how my complaint had been resolved.


I eventually sought an expungement and included the disputed conviction record in that request. That was the only way I found to remove it from public view, although expungement seals a record rather than erasing it.


My expungement paperwork describes an “incorrect cause number.” My concern goes beyond an incorrect number: The record stated that I had pleaded guilty to a Class C felony, and I maintain that no such plea or conviction ever occurred.


I have retained documents, including the judge’s denial letter, that I believe support my account.


I also have questions about disciplinary proceedings involving Franklin County attorney Tammy Davis, who ran against Judge Cox for judge. My understanding is that Cox filed complaints against her and that she received a serious sanction. That history leaves me questioning whether the disciplinary system treats everyone consistently.


My experience has deeply damaged my confidence in Indiana’s judicial oversight system. The controversy surrounding Judge Fran Gull has further eroded that trust.


I hope you continue reporting on judicial conduct and the commission’s handling of complaints. People who bring concerns forward deserve clear answers about what was investigated, what was decided, and why.

Thank you for covering these issues and helping bring public attention to judicial accountability.

Sincerely,


Shannon McHenry

Connersville, Indiana



HE Editor’s Response:

So many have experienced the injustice system of Indiana. Your’s is the first letter we have published because it is emblematic of the Loretta Rush courts and poor management. We cannot understand why she was allowed or have wanted another term or why the voters in Indiana retained her? She was never qualified as a legal candidate or small county family law court with a less than impressive record. HE has called for resignation, impeachment and is only beginning to investigate her travel records, expense reports and how others view her. So many have expressed support for her removal and many talented jurists are willingly, ready and able to right the sinking ship she has so clueless wrecked. Sorry for your ordeal. God will be the ultimate judge of these Individuals.



bottom of page