Hoosier Enquirer Hosts Megan Stoner for Exclusive Live Interview Addressing Legal Controversies

Gabe Whitley interviews Megan Stoner.

On the evening of May 18, 2025, the Hoosier Enquirer welcomed Megan Stoner to its live show for a candid and unfiltered discussion about the legal troubles and public allegations that have surrounded her in recent years. The two-hour segment, hosted by Gabe Whitley, provided Stoner an opportunity to share her perspective on a series of charges and controversies, ranging from rental scams to allegations of identity fraud. The interview, which aired at 10 PM EST, sparked significant interest, with viewers tuning in to hear Stoner’s side of the story for the first time in a public forum.

Gabe Whitley and his Co-host Johannes Poulard interview Megan Stoner about the rental property snafue.

The Hoosier Enquirer’s interview covered a wide range of topics, delving into the complexities of Stoner’s case and her experiences in Indiana’s legal and political spheres. The questions posed by Whitley were designed to address the allegations head-on, giving Stoner a platform to clarify her actions and respond to the narratives that have circulated on social media and in local news. Below is a summary of the key questions asked during the live show, which aimed to unpack the events leading to her legal battles and their impact on her life.

The interview began with questions about how Stoner entered the world of apartment leasing and what circumstances led to the rental agreements that later resulted in legal issues. Whitley then addressed specific allegations from the Fishers Police Department, which claimed Stoner misrepresented herself as the owner of a home in Fishers, allegedly scamming victims into signing fraudulent leases. Stoner was asked to clarify her side of these accusations, which formed the basis of significant media coverage.

The discussion then turned to the serious charges filed against her in Hamilton County, Indiana, including 11 felonies such as theft, fraud, and conspiracy/racketeering. Whitley probed into the events that led to these charges and how Stoner responded to them. The conversation also touched on her time in the Hamilton County Jail after turning herself in on April 27, 2023, exploring the emotional and practical toll of incarceration.

A Change.org petition accusing Stoner of continuing fraudulent activities while out on bond was another focal point, with Whitley asking how she addressed claims of ongoing criminal behavior across multiple states. The interview also explored Stoner’s alleged connections to the Indiana State Legislature, questioning whether she held any official role or if her interactions were informal. Additionally, Whitley raised questions about rumored ties to former Vice President Mike Pence, seeking clarity on the nature of any relationship.

Allegations of identity fraud surfaced as a significant topic, with online claims suggesting Stoner misrepresented herself in various schemes. She was asked to address these accusations directly. Whitley also referenced a 2024 article in which a journalist described meeting Stoner under the alias “Abbi” while she was working as a Lyft driver, prompting questions about the use of a different name and the context of that encounter.

Stoner’s involvement in Indiana politics was another key area of discussion, with questions about her engagement in political circles during the time of her alleged activities and how her perspective on politics has evolved amid her legal challenges. The interview also examined the personal toll of the rental scheme allegations, including their impact on her relationships, reputation, and standing in her community.

Social media’s role in shaping public perception of Stoner’s case was addressed, with Whitley noting discussions on platforms like Reddit and Twitter, where some have even called for a true crime podcast about her story. Stoner was asked how these narratives have affected her and how she responds to the public scrutiny. The interview concluded with questions about the steps she has taken since her arrest to address the charges, rebuild her life, and make amends with those who claim to have been harmed, as well as reflections on her current life and future plans.

The live show, which was streamed on the Hoosier Enquirer’s website and YouTube channel, is also available as a podcast episode on platforms including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, Google Podcasts, and iHeartRadio. For those who missed the broadcast, the full interview can be accessed on these platforms, offering a comprehensive look at Stoner’s account of the events that have defined her recent years.

You can listen to the interview on Spotify.

The Hoosier Enquirer has also announced a follow-up segment scheduled for June 1, 2025, inviting individuals who wish to dispute Stoner’s claims to come forward and share their perspectives. This decision reflects the outlet’s commitment to fostering open dialogue about a case that has generated significant controversy and debate within Indiana communities.

As the Hoosier Enquirer continues to cover stories that matter to Hoosiers, this interview with Megan Stoner stands out as a bold attempt to navigate a complex and polarizing narrative. Whether viewers see Stoner’s appearance as a step toward accountability or a platform for self-defense, the conversation has undoubtedly added new layers to an ongoing story that continues to captivate public attention.

The Hoosier Enquirer is an independent, nonprofit media organization under section 501(c)3, dedicated to delivering real, honest news in the Hoosier State.