Hoosier Enquirer

Your Source for Indiana News

Indiana News

Breaking News

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

top of page

Why Does a Bartender Need to Know Where You Live? Indiana's Digital ID Debate Raises a Larger Question About Privacy

1 day ago
8 min read

As neighboring states introduce mobile driver's licenses, Indiana is moving toward a system that could allow residents to prove their age without surrendering their addresses, birthdates and other personal information. But the technology also raises new questions about surveillance, security and government oversight in a time of system failures.


INDIANAPOLIS — The transaction takes only a few seconds. A customer orders a drink, reaches into a wallet and hands a driver's license to a bartender. The bartender checks the date of birth, perhaps examines the photograph, and returns the card.


It is a familiar ritual in bars, restaurants, liquor stores and entertainment venues across Indiana. Yet buried in that routine exchange is an increasingly consequential question about personal privacy: Why must someone reveal a home address, full legal name and other identifying information simply to establish that they are old enough to buy a beer?

In an era when businesses collect extraordinary amounts of information about their customers, the humble driver's license has become an unexpectedly revealing document.

A card designed to establish driving privileges now functions as a universal identification credential, routinely presented to people who have no legitimate need to know where its holder lives.


And in establishments equipped with surveillance cameras or electronic identification scanners, the information may be exposed to more than the employee standing behind the counter.


Indiana is preparing to join a growing number of states offering mobile driver's licenses, a technology that could fundamentally change these interactions. Instead of displaying an entire identification card, a customer could use a smartphone to provide a digitally authenticated answer to a much narrower question: Is this person at least 21 years old?

The distinction may sound modest. Its implications for consumer privacy are anything but.


Indiana's Long-Awaited Digital License


Indiana lawmakers authorized mobile identification credentials in 2019, establishing a legal foundation for digital alternatives to conventional driver's licenses.


Yet seven years later, Hoosiers still cannot obtain a statewide mobile driver's license through an operational Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles program.


During a legislative presentation in September, BMV officials described plans to introduce optional mobile credentials within approximately 18 months, suggesting a possible rollout in early 2028.


That timetable remains a projection rather than a guaranteed launch date.

The agency has indicated that the credentials would supplement traditional licenses rather than replace them, and that residents would not be charged an additional fee to obtain the mobile version.


The technology would allow a government-issued credential to be stored securely on a compatible smartphone and verified electronically by participating businesses or government agencies.


Unlike a photograph of a driver's license, which can be copied or altered, a properly implemented mobile credential uses cryptographic protections to establish authenticity.

More significantly, it can limit the information disclosed during a transaction.

A retailer checking whether a customer is 21 need not automatically receive the customer's exact date of birth, residential address or driver's license number.


That principle, known as selective disclosure, represents one of the most important developments in digital identity technology.


It also presents Indiana with a choice: Will the state merely reproduce the traditional driver's license on a smartphone, or will it use the transition to rethink how much personal information businesses should be entitled to collect?


A Driver's License Reveals More Than Most People Realize


Consider what happens when someone presents a physical driver's license at a crowded Indianapolis nightclub.


The employee examining the card may see the customer's full name, photograph, birthdate, address and identification number.


Depending on the establishment, the transaction may occur beneath security cameras. Some businesses also use scanners that read information from the machine-readable barcode on the back of the license.


Not every business retains that information, and an overhead camera does not necessarily capture a readable image of a license. But the possibility of unnecessary collection is real.

A driver's license is particularly valuable to identity thieves because it combines multiple pieces of personally identifying information in a single document.


The consumer generally has little practical control over which details an employee sees or whether the information is recorded.


A customer who objects can decline to present the license, but that may mean being denied entry or service.


Mobile identification could alter that imbalance.


With a properly designed system, a bartender could request confirmation that the customer satisfies the legal drinking-age requirement. The customer's smartphone could transmit an authenticated response without revealing a residential address.


The employee would receive the information necessary to complete the transaction, and little else.


Such a system would not eliminate every privacy risk. But it could significantly reduce the routine disclosure of information that has become so commonplace that few people question it.


Indiana's Neighbors Are Already Experimenting


Indiana would not be entering unfamiliar territory. Lord knows the state can't run a legal system--just ask the Attorney General...now this.


Ohio has introduced mobile driver's licenses and identification cards through supported smartphone wallets, allowing residents to present digital credentials at participating verification locations.


Illinois has also moved into mobile identification, offering digital credentials through Apple Wallet and providing tools for businesses to verify them. State lawmakers have adopted additional protections governing how identification information may be accessed and retained.


Kentucky has developed its own mobile identification program, offering a digital credential that supplements the traditional driver's license.


Michigan, meanwhile, has considered legislation addressing mobile identification and associated privacy protections.


The neighboring states have not adopted identical systems. Their programs differ in technology, acceptance, verification procedures and legal safeguards.


Nor does possession of a mobile license guarantee that every bar, retailer or police department will accept it.


That distinction matters. A digital credential is useful only when businesses and government agencies have the equipment, software and legal authority to recognize it.

Still, the movement across the Midwest demonstrates that mobile identification is no longer a speculative technology awaiting some distant breakthrough.


The larger challenge is designing a system that businesses will actually use and consumers can trust.


The Case for Showing Less, Not More


Indiana's existing laws provide a starting point.


Legislation enacted in 2023 strengthened the state's framework for mobile identification, including provisions concerning security and protections against tracking.

I

ndiana law also recognizes an important principle: Presenting a mobile credential does not, by itself, authorize someone to search the other contents of a person's smartphone.

That safeguard is especially important in encounters involving law enforcement.


A driver who presents a digital license should not thereby grant access to private messages, photographs, financial records or unrelated applications.


But protecting the contents of a smartphone is only one part of the privacy equation.

Equally important is determining what happens to the information transmitted from the digital credential.


Could a bar retain the customer's name and birthdate? Could a retailer create a database of identification checks? Could a technology provider collect information about where and when a credential is presented?


A well-designed system should minimize those possibilities.

For ordinary age verification, the default should be an authenticated yes-or-no response, rather than disclosure of a complete identity record.


Businesses with legitimate legal obligations to collect additional information could request it under clearly defined circumstances.


The governing principle should be straightforward: The amount of personal information disclosed should correspond to the actual purpose of the transaction.


The Unanswered Question of Surveillance


Digital identification is often promoted as a security improvement. It can be one. But technology that reduces one form of surveillance can also create opportunities for another.

A physical driver's license does not ordinarily notify the government every time it is displayed.


A poorly designed digital system, by contrast, could theoretically create records showing where and when a credential was used.


Those records could become valuable to advertisers, data brokers, businesses or government investigators.


The American Civil Liberties Union and other privacy advocates have warned that digital identity programs require safeguards against tracking, unauthorized access and the potential loss of access to essential identification credentials.


Those concerns do not necessarily argue against mobile licenses. They argue for careful design and enforceable limitations.


Indiana should make clear that its system will not create a centralized database of residents' visits to bars, pharmacies, hotels or entertainment venues.


The state should also require transparency about the role of private technology vendors, including what information they can access and whether any transaction records are retained.


A mobile driver's license that allows a bartender to see less information would be an improvement. A mobile driver's license that allows an unseen third party to monitor every identification check would be a troubling trade-off.


What About Hoosiers Who Do Not Want a Digital License?


Not everyone owns a smartphone. Not everyone wants government-issued identification stored on one. Older residents, people with limited incomes and those who simply prefer physical documents should not be disadvantaged by the transition.


Indiana officials have described mobile credentials as optional, and that distinction should remain central to the program. Traditional licenses should continue to be issued and accepted.


Likewise, consumers should not be required to surrender their phones to employees or police officers merely to display a digital credential. The ideal verification process would allow the phone to remain in its owner's possession while a compatible reader requests and receives only the information necessary.


Such protections would help establish public confidence while preserving meaningful consumer choice. NOT MANDATORY, a choice.


The Cost of Getting It Right


Indiana also has financial questions to answer. As of the September legislative presentation, the BMV had not publicly established a final comprehensive cost estimate or vendor arrangement for the program.


A statewide mobile identification system could involve software development, security testing, credential issuance, technical support and ongoing maintenance.

Participating businesses may also need compatible verification equipment.


For a large retail chain, the expense might be manageable. For a neighborhood tavern or small independent liquor store, it could present another operating cost.

Indiana should examine whether inexpensive verification applications can reduce those barriers.


Illinois has offered a model worth studying by providing a mobile identification verification application for participating businesses. The state should also disclose the financial arrangements governing its technology providers, including whether vendors would receive recurring payments or gain access to transaction-related information.


Taxpayers and consumers deserve to know not only how much the program will cost, but also who will control the underlying technology.


A Consumer-Protection Opportunity Beyond the Smartphone


There is a broader question Indiana lawmakers should consider. Even if mobile licenses become widely available, many Hoosiers will continue presenting traditional identification cards for years. Should businesses be permitted to scan, photograph or retain the residential addresses and license numbers of customers when the only legitimate purpose is to verify age?


Indiana could consider additional consumer-protection rules limiting unnecessary collection and retention of driver's license information. Such legislation would require careful exceptions for circumstances in which businesses are legally obligated to verify or record particular identifying details. But the basic distinction is important.


Verifying that a customer is old enough to purchase alcohol is not the same as establishing a comprehensive customer identity record. A bartender does not ordinarily need to know where a patron lives. A liquor store clerk generally does not need to know the customer's driver's license number merely to establish legal age.


The same question arises at concerts, casinos, sporting events and other venues where identification is routinely demanded.


Digital credentials offer an opportunity to change expectations about what businesses may reasonably request.


A Test of Indiana's Approach to Privacy


Indiana has spent years establishing the legal groundwork for mobile identification. Its neighbors have moved ahead with operational programs, and state officials now anticipate introducing their own system.


The next stage will determine whether the technology delivers meaningful benefits.

The BMV should provide a firm implementation schedule, explain its privacy architecture, identify participating technology providers and clarify how businesses will verify credentials.

Lawmakers should examine whether existing consumer-protection statutes adequately restrict unnecessary identification scanning and retention.


And the state should establish clear rules ensuring that residents cannot be tracked simply because they use government-issued digital identification. The strongest case for mobile identification is not that it eliminates the need to carry another piece of plastic. It is that the technology could restore a measure of privacy that Americans have gradually surrendered in ordinary commercial transactions.


For decades, consumers have been expected to reveal far more about themselves than necessary simply to establish their age. Indiana now has an opportunity to change that practice.


The question is whether the state will recognize that a driver's license contains information belonging to the person who carries it—not to every bartender, retailer or business that asks to see it.


Proving that you are 21 should not require telling a stranger where you live.



bottom of page