Hoosier Enquirer

Your Source for Indiana News

Indiana News

Breaking News

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

top of page

Indiana's Disposable Vape Problem: Should The IGA Levy a $20 Tax Help End the Era of Throwaway Nicotine?

19 minutes ago
5 min read
Just another dumpster fire in Indiana...go figure.
Just another dumpster fire in Indiana...go figure.

Flavored nicotine products are only part of the story. Millions of disposable electronic devices create a growing national waste problem involving lithium batteries, toxic nicotine and fire risks. Indiana already taxes vaping, but who pays for the trash? YOU DO....



By the Hoosier Enquirer Editorial Board

INDIANAPOLIS — November 16, 2026 — Indiana has spent years regulating electronic cigarettes through age restrictions, licensing requirements and excise taxes. Yet one of the most consequential questions about vaping has received comparatively little public attention: What happens when a disposable electronic cigarette is finished and its owner throws it into the trash?


Unlike an ordinary cigarette butt, a disposable vape is an electronic device containing a battery, circuitry, plastic components and potentially toxic nicotine residue. Millions of such products are sold nationally, often in brightly colored packaging and flavors ranging from fruit to candy. Their convenient design creates an inconvenient problem for the people responsible for collecting and processing America's garbage.


The Environmental Protection Agency warns that lithium batteries in discarded vapes can ignite when damaged by trash compactors, collection vehicles or recycling equipment. Nicotine residues also present hazards to workers and the environment. EPA specifically advises consumers not to place e-cigarettes in ordinary trash or recycling bins.


Indiana already imposes a substantial tax on vaping products. But the tax system is primarily a revenue mechanism, not a comprehensive program for preventing battery fires or financing safe collection and disposal.


That raises a legitimate question for the 2027 General Assembly: Should Indiana impose an additional $10 tax on disposable vapes, require manufacturers to pay for collection and disposal, or consider phasing out single-use battery-powered nicotine devices altogether?


Indiana Already Taxes Vaping at 30%


Indiana prohibits sales of electronic cigarettes and e-liquids to people under 21, consistent with federal law. The state also imposes penalties for underage purchases and violations by retailers, requires appropriate retail credentials and restricts the location of tobacco and vaping shops near public schools.


The state increased its vaping excise taxes effective July 1, 2025. Closed-system cartridges, including self-contained disposable vapes, are subject to a 30% wholesale excise tax. Open-system vaping products and e-liquids are subject to a separate 30% retail excise tax. Indiana's 7% sales tax also applies.


The distinction matters because a $10 tax on each disposable device would be considerably different from the current percentage-based system. It would establish a substantial fixed cost for each throwaway electronic cigarette, regardless of its wholesale value.


A disposable device with an $8 wholesale value, for example, generates $2.40 in wholesale excise tax under the existing system. An additional $10 per-device tax would bring the combined excise burden to $12.40 before considering sales tax and pricing adjustments.

Such a change would require careful economic analysis. It could discourage purchases of inexpensive disposable devices, but it could also shift consumers toward products sold outside Indiana or through illegal channels.


The Flavor Question: What Is Actually Legal?


Indiana does not have a blanket statewide prohibition on every flavored vaping product. But that does not mean retailers can legally sell any flavored disposable they choose.

Federal law requires tobacco products, including e-cigarettes, to have the appropriate FDA marketing authorization unless another lawful marketing status applies. The FDA's current list identifies 48 authorized e-cigarette products, including tobacco, menthol and certain other flavors.


The federal government has authorized only a limited number of products compared with the much larger selection of disposable vapes commonly advertised in the marketplace.

In its 2025 National Youth Tobacco Survey, the FDA reported that 89.4% of current youth e-cigarette users used flavored products. Disposable devices accounted for 66.3% of the devices used by students who reported current vaping.


Those national figures help explain why flavored disposable products remain a public-health concern. They do not establish the number of Indiana students vaping or the number of unauthorized products sold within the state.


Indiana's Alcohol and Tobacco Commission has also issued notices concerning products associated with foreign adversaries, reflecting additional state regulatory activity in 2026.

Before enacting new restrictions, lawmakers should examine whether existing laws are being enforced effectively, including whether stores are selling products without required federal authorization.


The Hidden Fire Risk in Indiana's Garbage


The environmental issue is particularly important because the battery in a disposable vape does not become harmless when the nicotine liquid runs out.


Lithium-ion batteries can retain electrical energy after the device is no longer usable. When a discarded vape is crushed, punctured or otherwise damaged, its battery may overheat and ignite nearby combustible material.


A fire inside a garbage truck or recycling facility can endanger workers, damage expensive equipment, interrupt operations and generate emergency response and insurance costs.

EPA has documented these risks nationally and warns that vaping devices should be delivered to appropriate household hazardous-waste collection programs.


Indiana's Department of Environmental Management provides information about household hazardous-waste disposal and directs residents to local solid waste management districts. However, ordinary consumers may not know where to take a used vape, and dedicated collection opportunities are not necessarily convenient or consistent across communities.

The state should determine how many discarded vaping devices enter Indiana's waste stream, how frequently batteries from such devices contribute to fires, and what additional costs are incurred by local governments and private waste operators.


Without those figures, policymakers cannot accurately calculate the economic burden of disposable vaping products.


Who Pays for the Cleanup?


Some states, like Arizona, are tackling this issue. How about here? Where is the news media on this one? Just like they are on Loretta Rush and the Indiana Court System: AWOL.


The people who manufacture and sell disposable vapes earn revenue when the devices are purchased. The costs of managing the discarded products may fall on waste districts, municipalities, recycling companies, landfill operators and taxpayers.


That creates a potential mismatch between private profits and public costs.


One response would be a manufacturer-funded collection system requiring companies to finance safe disposal of their products. Another would be a refundable deposit that encourages consumers to return used devices to authorized collection sites.


A third possibility is a dedicated environmental fee or excise tax, with the proceeds used for hazardous-waste collection, fire prevention and recycling infrastructure.


A $10 tax could be considered as part of that approach, but lawmakers should not assume that $10 represents the actual environmental cost of every discarded vape. A defensible fee would require evidence concerning collection expenses, fire losses, transportation, processing and disposal.


The state should also examine whether manufacturers can redesign products to reduce battery waste, including using durable rechargeable devices rather than permanently sealed single-use electronics.


Should Indiana Tax Disposable Vapes Out of Existence?


A sufficiently high excise tax could make disposable vaping less economically attractive, especially for consumers purchasing inexpensive products. But eliminating a product through taxation is not the same as eliminating demand.


Higher prices can reduce consumption, particularly among price-sensitive purchasers. They can also encourage consumers to seek untaxed products, travel across state lines or purchase from unauthorized sellers.


There is an additional public-health consideration. Some adults who smoke combustible cigarettes use e-cigarettes as a lower-risk alternative when they switch completely. FDA has recognized that benefit in authorizing certain vaping products, while continuing to warn that e-cigarettes are not harmless.


Indiana should therefore distinguish between disposable products that create substantial electronic waste and reusable systems that may offer adult smokers an alternative to combustible.


This what the Indiana Attorney General, Todd Rokita, needs to address not to be wasting time fighting bogus ethics case brought by Loretta Rush to show who is boss. Clearly there is real work to do.


Tax the bejesus out of these products and companies hooking our kids on vapes.

bottom of page