Corruption Update: Indiana Ex-Cop Tim Corbett's Plot Still Uncorrected- Rev. Sim's Effort to Get His Criminal Case Dismissed FAILED This Month, Somehow?

Former St. Joseph Metro Police Officer Tim Corbett admitted to planting evidence on black men in the South Bend area in the 1990’s.

Indianapolis, Indiana: 02-11-2025 5:30am EST; Updated 6:52 am EST

Mario Sims filed this in pleading for correction of errors by Indiana Judge David Francisco recently with the Court:

1. On August 5, 2026, Defendant filed his “VERIFIED MOTION TO

DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE.”

2. The party charged by law St.Joseph County Prosecutor's office,

filed no response or opposition and therefore the following allegation

therein were uncontroverted:

“ Mario L. Sims, “VERIFIED MOTION TO DISMISS WITH

PREJUDICE.” states:

1. Tim Corbett filed suit in Cause Number 71C01-2103-CT-

000094, in 2020 for defamation agsint Mario L. Sims based

upon the attached letter.

2. On May 19, 2026, St. Joseph Superior Court Judge David

Francisco in the attached Order in Cause Number 71C01-

2103 CT-000094 dismissed Corbett's suit with prejudice

after determining could not prove what was contained in

Mario Sims letter in the six years his suit pended about

Corbett planting evidence in criminal Case Number 71D02-

9401-CF 000060, State of Indiana v. Mario L. Sims in 1994,

was not true.

3. Further, the wrongful actions being published in major

media outlets detail Tim Corbett's criminal acts while

employed by the City and the County and in Orders of

other court cases where men have been released from

prison because of the same 1 criminal acts committed by

Tim Corbett's in criminal Case Number 71D01 9401-CF-

00060, State of Indiana v. Mario L. Sims in 1994, while

employed by the City and the County.

4. The attached affidavit of Jesse Davis under oath of

Corbett confessing to planting evidence in to a Reporter

then threatening to kill her when she disclosed publically

what he had told her to Derek Dieter, Pat Cotrell, Officer

Davin Hackett and Jesse Davis which supports this motion

also.

5. The County and City concealed the truth of those acts

from Mario Sims, even committing fraud upon the court by

obtaining a procedural bar in Scopelitis it knew was not

true in criminal Case Number 71D01 9401-CF-00060.

6. Authorities in South Bend and the St, Joseph County

Prosecutor knew about and used for years Corbett's

criminal acts while hiding behind Scopelitis to deny Mario

Sims justice in criminal Case Number 71D01 9401-CF-

00060, State of Indiana v. Mario L. Sims and civil cases

filed to show the existence of a conspiracy, all to cover up

Corbett's criminal acts . The County and City concealed

the truth of those acts from Mario Sims, even committing

fraud upon the court by obtaining a procedural bar in

Scopelitis it knew was not truth 2 effectively denying

Mario Sims access to the appellate courts.

7. Mario Sims can produce witnesses and testimony at any

evidentiary hearing to prove the truth of this matter

including evidence of Tim Corbett committing murders.

Also covered up by City and County officials.”

3. St. Joseph Superior Court Judge David Francisco presided

both in Cause Number 71C01-2103 CT-000094 and in this case.

4. In Cause Number 71C01-2103 CT-000094 St. Joseph Superior

Court Judge David Francisco, a former Elkhart County Deputy Prosecutor

allowed uncontroverted and or unethical or criminal acts allowed or that

he ignored.

5. The Defendant has brought several criminal acts to the

attention of Judge David Francisco only to have those uncontroverted

facts ignored or excused.

6. Those facts include Defendant alleging in his uncontroverted

filings before Judge David Francisco, in Civil Case Cause Number 71C01-

2103 CT-000094, that the Plaintiff in that case, a former St. Joseph County

law enforcement officer used by St. Joseph County Judge John Marnocha

to wrongly gain the conviction of, Mario Sims threatening the Defendant's

attorney John Cantrell so he would not appear. Defendant's allegation was

uncontroverted and the Defendant request a evidentiary hearing to offer

testimony and evidence, which the court simply ignored.

Remember HE. broke this news story with the following original reporting. Elkhart County has had a number dirty cop convictions now overturned which HE is following and will report on too in the future.

While many police officers have state now publicly and privately their realizaiton that bad stuff was happening and they were suspect and now know it, not much has happened to bring justice to South Bend. Maybe a new mayor next year will be the solution everyone wants and needs, since HE reported the following story:

In the heart of South Bend area, Indiana, a story of alleged corruption, deceit, and intimidation has emerged, casting a long shadow over the legacy of Tim Corbett, a former officer of the St. Joseph Metro Police and current member of the South Bend Community School Corp. Board. This narrative not only questions the integrity of one man's career but also the systemic practices within the police force and the influence of political affiliations on legal proceedings.

Tim Corbett’s Official Police Picture from St Joseph Metro Police Department

The Genesis of the Allegations

The story begins with a personal connection turned into a professional scandal. Alexis Gray, now known as Alexis Rivas Shear, was once romantically involved with Corbett. Years later, this past relationship would come back to haunt both when Rivas Shear, then an investigative journalist for ABC21 News and later for NBC Universal Media, LLC, uncovered a series of disturbing admissions from Cobertt.

In April 2019, Rivas Shear reached out to Mario Sims, who had transitioned from an accused felon to a respected Senior Pastor at Doulos Chapel. Sims had been convicted of rape in 1994 under Case Number: 71D02-9401-CF-000060, a conviction that would later be questioned based on new revelations. During her visit to the church, Rivas Shear revealed to Sims that Cobertt had confessed to her about planting evidence against him and possibly other black men during his tenure as a police officer. This confession was recorded, marking a pivotal moment in this unfolding narrative.

Mario Sims was targeted by Former Police Officer Tim Corbett

The Immediate Aftermath

The interview was cut short by an urgent call from Rivas Shear's station, where she was advised of her status as a witness to a crime due to Corbett’s admission. This revelation not only endangered her but also highlighted the potential for a miscarriage of justice. Frightened by the implications of her findings, Rivas Shear suggested to Sims that he wait before taking public action, as she needed time to strategize with her station about the next steps.

After a week of silence, Pastor Sims, concerned for both his safety and the truth, contacted Rivas Shear, only to find her fearful for her life. This fear was not unfounded; another reporter, Jacklyn Kelly, had previously been harassed to the extent she had to leave Southbend, allegedly at the behest of someone under Cobertt's command when he was St. Joseph Metro Homicide Commander. Moreover, Sims himself had been the target of harassment, leading to several police reports filed with both the Indiana State Police and St. Joseph Metro Police.

• 

• 

Alexis Rivas Shear is on the right and Jacklyn Kelly on the left.

Political Dimensions and Retaliation

The story takes a darker turn with the political motivations behind Sims' prosecution. Initially running as a Democrat, Sims switched to the Republican party in a subsequent election cycle. This change in political allegiance, according to Sims, led to his being targeted by the Democratic establishment, which he claims was racially biased against black candidates. His ex-wife, who passed away four years after his release from prison, reportedly admitted to lying under oath, claiming she was coerced by Corbett’s threats.

This case illustrates a potential abuse of power where law enforcement might have been used as a tool for political retribution, highlighting a disturbing intersection of race, politics, and justice in Southbend.

The Media's Role and Alleged Suppression

The media's silence on this issue has been as telling as the allegations themselves. Gannet, a major player in local news media and known for its affiliations with Democratic donors, has been accused of suppressing this story. Despite reaching out for comment, Gannet has not responded, leaving an open question about media influence in local politics and justice.

Attempts at Accountability

Attempts to seek accountability have been met with resistance or silence:

- Official Reports: Rivas Shear made police reports with Officer Davin Hackett at the Elkhart Police Department, informing several local figures, including former South Bend Board of Public Safety President Pat Cotrell and City Councilman Derek Dieter, who are also former police officers. These reports, however, have not sparked the expected investigations.

- Lack of Response: Both Corbett and the St. Joseph Metro Police have remained silent, neither confirming nor denying the allegations. This silence from the accused and his former department raises further questions about transparency and accountability.

The Broader Implications

This case is not just about Corbett or Sims; it's about the systemic issues it might reveal:

- Corruption in Law Enforcement: The allegations suggest a scenario where evidence was manipulated, undermining the very foundations of justice.

- Political Influence on Legal Outcomes: The narrative points to a potential misuse of legal systems for political gain, especially concerning racial dynamics in political representation.

- Media and Power: The alleged suppression by Gannet illustrates how media ownership might affect what stories are told or buried, impacting public perception and justice.

- Community Trust: Incidents like these erode public trust in both law enforcement and the media, critical pillars of society.

The Current Standoff

As of now, the story hangs in a balance, with no clear resolution in sight. The lack of response from key figures and institutions involved does little to quell the controversy or bring closure to those affected. For Sims, Rivas Shear, and the community of South Bend, the fight for truth and justice continues, with hopes pinned on further investigations or a shift in public and official acknowledgment of these serious allegations.

All of this was confirmed through our research investigators at Hoosier Enquirer, we reached out to every living person involved in this case.

Official Court Documents:

We reached out to both Corbett and the St. Joseph Metro Police but haven't received any responses. We also asked for the videotape interview where Tim admitted to planting evidence on black men, specifically targeting Mario Sims, but ABC 21 has not replied either.

The Hoosier Enquirer will continue to follow this story, providing updates as more information becomes available.

For more local political news, stay tuned to the Hoosier Enquirer

Follow Hoosier Enquirer on Facebook, X, Instagram, YouTube, LinkedIn and TikTok.

Corruption Unveiled: Indiana Ex-Cop Tim Corbett's Sinister Plot - Framing Innocents, Hunting Whistleblowers in Southbend's Darkest Hour -Hoosier Exclusive / First Seen On Hoosier Enquirer.